The Strokes

The Strokes arrived complete. That is the first and most important thing to say about them — *Is This It* did not announce a band finding its voice but one that had already found it, sharpened it, and begun using it against itself. What Julian Casablancas discovered on that debut, and what the band has spent seven records and a quarter century elaborating, is that the most honest thing you can say about modern consciousness is that it sees through everything and changes nothing. The through-line is not love or loss or New York City, though all three appear on nearly every record — it is the gap between perception and agency, the condition of understanding exactly what is wrong and proceeding anyway. This is what separates The Strokes from their contemporaries: not the guitar tones or the haircuts but the specific philosophical position their lyrics occupy, which is neither nihilism nor hope but something more corrosive and more durable: lucid despair dressed in the vocabulary of the everyday.

The early records work from a shared emotional geography — the hours between midnight and 4 a.m., the city bar, the apartment entered under false pretenses — and they populate that geography with a figure who is, crucially, not a rebel. The narrator of *Is This It* has no interest in burning anything down. "I said the right things but act the wrong way" is not a cry of defiance; it is a diagnostic note, the kind a doctor makes after an examination he already knew was going to come out badly. The album's founding gesture is the admission in the opener — "I just lied to get to your apartment" — and everything that follows is a variation on that lie: "Promises, they break before they're made," the grammatical paradox of "Someday" making betrayal feel structural rather than personal. What gives *Is This It* its electricity is that it is not depressed about this condition. It is awake to it, even briefly exhilarated by the clarity, which is why the album sounds like a party being held in a condemned building and why it still feels like nothing else.

*Room on Fire* is where the exhilaration cools. The figure who moves through those eleven tracks has aged by damage, and the record's most decisive move is to remove even the residual glamour that *Is This It* permitted its narrator. "I wanna be forgotten / And I don't want to be reminded" opens the album, and the desire for erasure is genuinely new — not the hip detachment of the debut but something rawer, the wish of someone who has tried the performing-of-indifference and discovered it hollows you out faster than genuine feeling would. The album's most devastating line — "You trained me not to love after you showed me what it was" from "Meet Me in the Bathroom" — arrives with the force of a theorem, clinical and annihilating simultaneously. What *Room on Fire* sacrifices in kinetic energy it gains in compression; it is the band's tightest argument, a record that narrows its sonic and emotional palette not from lack of imagination but because the subject, the morning-after texture of failed connection, demands that kind of discipline. Critics misread it as retreat. It was refinement.

*First Impressions of Earth* is where the compression breaks. The band's third record is overloaded, claustrophobic, guitars layering over guitars while the narrators inside the songs disengage entirely — and that structural irony is the album's central argument. The pursuit has ended, and nobody won. Where the first two records carried the energy of someone still running toward or away from something, *FIOE* is the sound of the running having stopped. "I hate them all / I hate myself / For hating them," from "On the Other Side," is the album's emotional signature: self-loathing that has completed its recursive circuit, turned inward on itself so many times it has become almost meditative. The album reaches for political and social diagnosis in ways the earlier records only gestured at — "Ize of the World," "Electricityscape," "15 Minutes" — and it reaches with genuine urgency, even as "Ask Me Anything"'s repeated "I've got nothing to say" confesses the paralysis that undermines the urgency. This is the album where cool detachment stopped being a pose and became, terrifyingly, a personality — and the brutal self-awareness of that discovery makes it, against its own intentions, the most unguarded thing the band had made to that point.

After the six-year silence, *Angles* arrives with a new target: the social machinery rather than the private wound. The album's most significant lyrical shift is from interiority to surveillance — suddenly these songs are populated by people watching themselves being watched, voices that "aren't yours but someone else's," animals on television "singing about some pain" as a substitute for the real thing. "Silently obsessed with death / Just like anyone, I guess" is the album's emotional signature, and that qualifier — "just like anyone" — is genuinely new in the catalog, a shrug that contains a scream and refuses to distinguish between individual suffering and systemic condition. The notorious fractures within the band during recording are not audible as incoherence but as structural irony: a record about the impossibility of collective agency made by five people who could barely agree on a chord. *Angles* is unglamorous in a way none of the earlier records were, and that refusal to make alienation attractive marks a genuine evolution. *Comedown Machine*, released two years later, follows this logic into its quietest and most uncomfortable territory: managed numbness, the "tap out" of someone who has arranged their life to prevent crisis from arriving and who has paid for that arrangement in identity. "Can I waste all your time here on the sidewalk?" from "Call It Fate, Call It Karma" is perhaps the saddest line in the catalog — a person who frames potential intimacy as an imposition before it has been accepted or refused, self-erasure so habitual it passes for courtesy.

*The New Abnormal* and *Reality Awaits* form the late period's double movement, and together they constitute a genuine late-career achievement precisely because they refuse the consolations that late careers usually reach for. *The New Abnormal* is the band working against their own inherited aesthetic, replacing taut nervous energy with something more like ambient dread, Rick Rubin's production bathing the album in lush unhurried warmth while the lyrics describe stagnation and suppression without relief. "Bad Decisions"' Cold War geometry — "Moscow, 1972," "pick up your gun, put up those gloves" — transposes contemporary emotional paralysis into geopolitical theater, making the personal standoff feel both absurd and inevitable. "Not the Same Anymore" registers the cost of missed windows with devastating economy: "you'd make a better window than a door." And "Ode to the Mets" closes the album with Rubik's Cubes that won't solve and old friends swallowed by ocean, folk-parable language for thoroughgoing disillusionment that arrives with the weight of everything that came before it.

*Reality Awaits* takes the late-period logic to its furthest point, introducing for the first time in the catalog a narrator who acknowledges his own complicity in the wreckage — not just a witness or a diagnostician but someone who keeps going to the mall, keeps dancing in the acid rain, keeps reaching for connections he is already mourning. "I'm in love with a ghost" distills the entire arc into five words: longing directed at something that never existed with the clarity memory assigns it. The self-portrait in "Going Shopping" — the "7-foot zombie" auditioning different forms of numbness, trying on identities in the changing room — is the logical endpoint of a journey that began with a kid who lied to get into an apartment and at least had the animal energy of the lie. What remains is self-knowledge without leverage, which the album insists is still worth something. "The precise and honest naming of damage is an act worth performing" is the implicit thesis, and it is, after everything, a position that contains genuine defiance.

The throughline connecting all seven records is a formal one as well as a thematic one: the weaponized declarative sentence, stripped of ornament, that arrives as plain speech and lands as a small catastrophe. "Promises, they break before they're made." "You trained me not to love after you showed me what it was." "I've got nothing to say." "Can I waste all your time here on the sidewalk?" "I'm in love with a ghost." The Strokes have always written in a mode of deflected directness — lines that appear to explain themselves and refuse to, confessions dressed as accusations, demands addressed to recipients who do not respond. This syntactic habit enacts the album's central condition: language that opens doors while closing them, communication that performs connection while demonstrating its impossibility. The specific quality of Casablancas's vocal delivery, processed and slightly buried even in the early records, has always served this lyrical logic — a singer who sounds like he is reaching you from somewhere just out of reach, which is of course exactly where every narrator in this catalog actually lives.

What The Strokes's complete body of work says, heard in sequence, is something more specific than any individual album could deliver: that the failure of connection is not a problem with a solution but a condition with a history, and that the only honest artistic response is to document it with increasing precision across time, without flinching and without false comfort, until the documentation itself becomes the act of connection that the lyrics insist is impossible — which is the band's enduring, irreducible paradox, and the reason these records still matter.

◆ ◆ ◆